Divine Intervention?

Blast from the Past.

God-changes-path-of-rockets

…or Human Kindness?

by Jorie K.

 

Growing up in the Worldwide Church of God, I knew my parents’ beliefs were at odds with the world from as long as I can remember. For whatever reason, I do not remember cementing my parents’ beliefs as my own. By the time I was eleven, left to my own devices, I read the entire Bible, and in my estimation it was the most ridiculous book I’d ever read. I was pretty sure no God existed, especially after no one could answer the uncomfortable questions I asked about some of the particularly nasty things I found in the Old Testament.

Then, as an angry pre-teen who refused to submit to mindless cult mentality, I was sure no God existed. Yet, in my late adolescence, despite my atheism, I said a prayer anyway. This prayer was humbly offered in desperation deep into the night, at a critical moment in my life when I was a homeless run-away for so long that I was ready to accept any help that God would offer me. The very next day I was taken in by a wealthy family and given opportunities to excel in ways I had never imagined. To this day, I do not know where I would be if they had not given me a chance. Since then, because I believed my prayer for help was answered, this experience was a strong thread that kept me hanging on to my belief in God for a very, very long time.

Admittedly, I have never gone on a quest for God. I really believe just as many atheists do: If there is a God who wishes her presence to be known, she will make it crystal clear as to how exactly I should find her – or better yet, she will find me. Although I have not gone in search of God, I have kept my mind open and invite anyone who wants to talk about it with me, in a respectful logical manner, to feel free. I’ve listened to Mormons, Protestants, Baptists, Methodists, Catholics, and other non-denominational Christians – not to mention I grew up in an Adventist Christian cult. I’ve attended lots of different churches, listened to their preachers, and read the Bible. I’ve talked with people who believe in a higher power, but aren’t sure what exactly it is. I am a friend of a Buddhist from Thailand and a Muslim from Somalia who’ve both shared their views. I’ve read about general Native American beliefs and rituals. I have watched the Travel Channel where I’ve seen tribal people in remote jungles perform various religious sacraments and explain their beliefs. For all of the differences in these religions, the common threads that I found among them have less to do with God and more to do with the necessities of humans to survive in groups and deal with their fears about death and non-existence.

The more I learn about religion, the more fascinating it becomes. Also, the more I learn, the less likely it is that only one group ever got a spiritual ‘leg up’ from God over another group. It is more likely that all religions have had no divine guidance at all. Religion itself seems to be a product of the evolution of human creativity and ingenuity when it comes to social structure and emotional survival. Ironically, religion is a sort of proof for the very evolution many religions try to disprove.

The point of my waxing philosophical here is that through many years of listening and learning, what has made the most sense so far is atheism. But, my one answered prayer has long kept me perplexed. Was it really an answered prayer, or just a coincidence? Recently I began trying to reconcile that one answered prayer with other events in my life. Trying to find a comparable series of events that ended with a desirable result, only this time without a prayer to be determined the cause. Granted, I have never been as desperate in my life as I was in the moment when I last sincerely asked for something in a prayer. But, there was an incident recently that sufficiently convinced me that my answered prayer had more to do with humanity than divinity.

This recent incident revolves around my former dog George. I adopted him as a puppy from my local humane society, and I very seriously meant to keep him forever when I adopted him. I worked full time and was in college full time, but still I made time to walk George twice a day. I even took him to a dog day care on my longest work and school day. He was well cared for, happy and healthy. One day, somewhat unexpectedly, family problems prompted my fourteen-year-old sister to run away. My mother had a breakdown and was put in a mental institution. My legally blind father was too proud to do anything but keep his head down, go to work every day, tithe, and make it to church every Saturday. I decided to step in; needless to say working and going to college full-time while juggling my personal life left little time for poor George. It got to the point where, three years of loving and owning a really great dog culminated in my having to return him to the humane society (as per the contract signed upon adoption).

The humane society’s rule is that when someone surrenders an animal – they do not have the right to know what eventually happens to their former pet. If poor sweet George was put down or adopted by another family, I would never know which. I remember suffering extreme guilt and sorrow after giving up George. As silly as it may sound to some people, I had made a promise when I adopted him that I would not abandon him when the going got tough. But, I did. Not only did I abandon him, I probably even sentenced him to death. I cried privately and had nightmares about it for months. I always tried to tell myself that he was such a wonderful dog, that of course another family adopted him. I hoped with all my might that this was true. That was five years ago, and never since then had thoughts of George stopped popping up to haunt me.

A few months ago, I finally had the courage (and stability) to adopt another dog. In the city where I live, there is a park that allows dogs to run off-leash. I took my new dog there as soon as he was obedience trained. While I was at the dog park, a familiar looking dog sauntered up and sniffed me, then casually walked away. I knew immediately it was my old dog George. My heart skipped a beat. I chatted up his new owner and sure enough, the details jived. It was George, he was slower, older and much fatter, but there he was, happy and enjoying life with a new owner who cared enough to bring him to the park for some play time. I admit, I was a little heartbroken that he did not even recognize me after how much I had anguished over him. But, as the dog lovers say, dogs live in the present, not the past – we could learn a thing or two from them…

The point is, had I spent my nights in prayer while suffering with my guilt over possibly sending my poor pooch to the euthanasia table, I may have thought that God had answered my prayers when I saw George at the dog park. At first I thought maybe I was comparing apples to oranges here, surely a prayer for my peace of mind about a dog cannot compare to a prayer for my own personal well-being. I assure you, if any time in the past could come close to the anguish I felt the night I said my original ‘answered’ prayer, it was the night I tried to sleep after surrendering George, while my family was falling apart around me. But, that night I did not pray, I did not ask God to hear me. I only hoped with all my might that someone out there would have a big enough heart to take a chance and adopt a washed-up older dog instead of a cute wiggly puppy. And you know what, someone did.

When I think back about the answered prayer of my adolescence, it was really the open heart of a fellow human being that did the answering. I used to think God sent me this person as an angel to rescue me. Now I understand that this person, of their own accord, took it upon themselves to extend a hand when they clearly saw that I was down. It was another someone with a big enough heart to take a chance and interfere with someone else’s business to rescue a fellow human being in need. It was not divine intervention that saved me that day after all. It was human kindness, pure and simple.

 

Charlatan

There was an article (pg-3) in the latest Journal titled ‘United Pilgrim Crusade based on old WCG’. The author of this article wrote

The episode, titled “Charlatan,” starring Ed Asner, who plays newspaperman Lou Grant, deals with a fundamentalist Christian ministry based in Rosemead, Calif., noted for its beautifully landscaped campus and extensive expensive art collection, as well as a grand auditorium, among other things. I won’t overly delve into the plot but will point out interesting parallels that indicate where the episode’s writers may have gotten their inspiration: headlines in L.A.-area newspapers of the time.

A Salesman's Critique Of The Church Of God Sales Organizations

amb-aud2

Blast from the Past.


Having been through a few high powered sales training schools and being a professional salesman with a successful track record I feel qualified to critique the COG sales organizations and Herbert Armstrong the founder.

Back when he started, Armstrong was a bankrupt salesman, and he had just left another religious organization under adverse conditions as a result of disagreements over doctrine. He and many others were drifting sheep. Armstrong had nowhere to go and nothing to do, so he had nothing else to lose in his ventures.

Armstrong used his past business experience to start a new “company” which eventually became Worldwide Church Of God. He used his sales experience to start a new “customer base” which were his vulnerable fellow church members from the previous religious organization. He used his religious experience to develop his “product” line which became the Holy Days, Petra, The Elect, and Salvation (which were only available through his organization) very exclusive stuff. He knew there is a certain percentage of customers who like to buy products that are “a little different”, trendy, maybe even a little better than the rest so he designed this into his package.

All good salesmen must have a few good lines and stories to tell and it appears Armstrong borrowed quite a few from other genuine individuals and used them as if he (Armstrong) was the originator. He also stole Christian songs from his competitors, the Protestants, and re-wrote the words to suit his doctrine. This is similar to what the communists did when they re-wrote all history approximately 50 years ago and took control of Russia. All people born after that time would come up believing there was always only one way the communist way. Very dangerous programming going on here.

What better avenue was there for tax evasion than a company in the name of religion? What better product is there than one that is free and does not require any warehousing? What better customer is there than one that blindly takes your personal word for the product? What better conditions are there for a tyrant, where there are no hassles from anybody because everybody serves you and you serve nobody. This man Armstrong was onto something with huge profit potential yes this was his way out of the misery he was in.

As any savvy company would do Armstrong knew he had to identify the profile of his customers. Who are they, what do they like, how much will they spend, etc. And he went further to “filter out” any potentially bad customers with screening interviews. He was developing a sharp sales organization with safeguards built in for his future income, while he remained the sole proprietor of the company.

One of Armstrong’s favorite sales tactics was to tell his customers “don’t take my word for it go verify it on your own”. He knew most people would take his word for it, or, even if they checked it out they would see it through tainted glasses with his seed of confusion having already been planted in their heads. He pre-conditioned their thinking. It happens all the time in sales.

In the sales world there are two types of sales closing techniques (getting the customer buy your product) (1) High Pressure, and (2) Creative Armstrong used both.

What did Armstrong know about acquiring money? Well he understood the value of cheap radio programs and it how gives the false perception of “celebrity status” to the speaker (emcee or DJ) and he especially understood the value of direct mail. For each 1000 mail-outs there will be a free-will offering return of .5% to 10%. This can be substantial when the number of mail-outs are in the hundreds of thousands. What did he understand about developing repeat business from his customers stay in touch and make them feel good about their purchase. Offer follow-up service and beat down the competition (Protestants and Catholics). Was he good at it? Well you got sold didn’t you?

Armstrong knew he was selling nothing more than thin air so there had to be something more substantial for his customers to hang onto in return for their investment. After all they were literally giving all of their money to the Armstrong company, or its COG subsidiaries. Their reward would be exclusive entrance into the “Narrow Gate” VIP club and the members would be referred to as The Elect. The password at the door was simply “Obedience”. He would provide annual feasts for them, spending orgies (another chance to collect millions) in the most worldly places such as Tahoe, Hawaii, Branson, etc. Wow, this lavish organization was really pigging out on money, resorts, the whole nine yards. And if they didn’t have enough they simply asked the customers to take another tenth of their investment and send it in so they could have a better party.

Any well organized company has a training program where they train their sales agents to sell their products. They pay them enough to get by, give them perks, and pump them up with smoke. The Armstrong company did the same thing. They opened the Ambassador Sales Training & Management School in Pasadena, California. One of the favorites perks for the trainees were free women students who had to date them if they weren’t already spoken for. This was at the personal direction of President Armstrong. It also conditioned the trainees to expect this same thing from their future customers.

The ultimate prize for the graduating manager trainees from Ambassador Sales Academy was being given exclusive territory otherwise known as churches, made of up of many customers called the brethren. When the territory became large enough the managers would appoint (anoint?) an assistant manager known as an Elder and a few goffers known as Deacons. You know the old barn yard thing throw a few scraps to the pigs and let them oink away.

What else can a good sales training organization do? They can teach the trainees a false perception and literally cause the trainees to spend the rest of their lives pushing a lousy product which they have been conditioned to think is the best product around. Happens everyday. This false perception even trickled into the minds of the customers. Most of the vain sales managers even claim Jesus to be their “elder brother”. Yeah, right!

You can judge a company by the success of their sales team. In the Armstrong company, and it’s subsidiaries, the sales agents and sales managers had new cars, nice homes, fine suits, lots of power & authority. As I have observed many times in my life there is a certain percentage of people who will fall at the feet of those with authority and this phenomenon was certainly happening in the COG organizations. The image they developed was such that the customers would not dare consider anything without first talking to their sales agent kind of like calling your stock broker before you buy stock.

The customers were so sold on the product that they would send huge amounts of money to the company, rather than buy the new car they needed, or the better house they needed, or the newer clothes they needed, or even to pay for a much needed “real” vacation free of stress where they could relax and unwind. In other words the customers were so drunk on product that they lost their ability to reason, to think prudently. In my opinion, very few scams have been as successful as this one was/is for such a long time. Operating under the guise of religion and with a well spun web so tangled that even the FBI could not break down the complex scheme. After all, the more money one makes, the more they tend to spin webs around it to protect it. The COGs were dealing in millions of dollars. No wonder some of the power hungry field reps tried to start their own COG organizations.

The COG organizations grew and the HO developed entire mind-sets to go by for the leaders in the field. They all sounded like identical twins with their sales pitches a good sign the program was working. Oh, I must add a footnote here that the name of God was used as a name-drop to let the brethren customers know who Armstrong was hobnobbing with. The name Jesus was not used very often because it came too close to identifying with the competition the Protestants and Catholics.

How did/does the HO leadership reward itself for a job well down? They take expensive vacations all over the world and call it business, opening a new company (church), for the purpose of taking it off as a tax deduction. The IRS requires that such trips must include “official meetings” to qualify for a break. The traveling VIPs claim to have opened a new church by finding some poor soul in a foreign land (vacation land) and talking them into being the host for future meetings. So now we have a new church an individual far away waiting for more instructions from the top. The vacationing VIPs probably left a few scraps behind to keep the farm going.

How creative can one get with the company name COG? Worldwide COG, Philadelphia COG, United COG, The Narrow Gate COG, Petra Group COG, Come And Get It COG, Lose Your Butt COG, etc. Seems like they will run out of names sooner or later. Some of them have the ignorance enough to claim their church name is directly authorized by God you know, Armstrong’s hobnob friend.

As a sales person I see where I could have had a dream life in the COG companies. An experienced salesman can empty your wallet and make you feel good about it. And if you come back for more well, well what a cream pie for the salesman.

As it is with many large organizations, some of the well trained employees who get the independent feeling, finally leave the company to set out on their own in direct competition with the company they left. This is still happening today as we continue to see more and more little shops open up with the original parent company name somewhere in the logo as “Church Of God”. The problems I see with these COG companies are: (1) The customers get ripped off worse than any scam I have ever seen before. (2) The product being offered is without any value and is a copy-cat product taken from another company Orthodox Jews, Inc. (3) The exclusive Salvation product being offered is not exclusive at all but rather a widely distributed product among other organizations. (4) The higher up leaders don’t even use their own product for some strange reason. (5) The propaganda literature used by the company is rife with ulterior motives, none of which have anything to do with concerns for customer satisfaction. (6) There is a danger of being trapped again by a spin-off claiming better treatment or new revelations.

As a salesman I see a bleak future for the company. They are too self-centered, money hungry, power driven, and they are being led by a dark horse named Mr Satanpower. This dark horse leader has an extensive history of ruthless control tactics with millions of lost souls left in his wake.

The casualties are speaking up now. Many of them are in counseling of one kind or another and the various psychologist, psychiatrists, and others seem to think the COG group is very definitely a cultic-type organization which over time literally destroys an individuals self esteem and identity.

If you want to learn a little more about the history of the Armstrong company and all of the COG subsidiaries, such as Global, United, Philadelphia, I recommend the Painful Truth web site. There you will be able to read about the personal experiences (nightmares?) of others who were bilked by the organization, first-hand testimony of the things I’ve mentioned in this article. A word of caution some of those individuals still have a hard time telling about their experiences without displaying anger and sometimes harsh words so be prepared for an expose’ that may melt your ear wax and make you mad, or even put you in temporary shock!

The brethren customers better run with their money while the gate is still open. Enjoy the rest of your life before it’s too late the COG leaders certainly do.

From The Sales Arena, Gladiator

THE THEORY OF SACRIFICE

CurvedWoodBackground

by SALOMON REINACH

1912

INTRODUCTION (excerpt)

In the eyes of the evolutionist—and we are all evolutionists

nowadays—man springs from beast, humanity from

animality. But man, take him where and when you

will, is a religious animal ; and religiosity, as the Positivist

would say, is the most essential of his attributes. It

can no longer be maintained, with Gabriel de Mortillet

and Hovelacque, that quaternary man was ignorant of

religion. Unless, then, we admit the gratuitous and

childlike hypothesis of a primitive revelation, we must

look for the origin of religions in the psychology, not

of civilised man, but of man the farthest removed from

civilisation.

Of this man, anterior to all history, we have no

direct knowledge, beyond what we glean from the implements

and artistic products of the quaternary period.

True, these teach us something, as I have striven to

show on a later page ; but, equally truly, they teach

us far less than we could wish. To supplement our

information, three other sources have to be tapped :

the psychology of the present-day savage, the psychology

of children, and the psychology of the higher animals.


THE THEORY OF SACRIFICE (1)

Chapter 2

Sacrifice is the crucial point of all cults, the essential bond between man and deity. In this respect it is comparable to prayer ; but whereas the latter is a spiritual appeal, the former entails the employment of a material substance forfeited or destroyed in the sacrificial act.

The general conception of sacrifice is that of a gift offered by man to the divinity in order to conciliate his favour ; in other words, it is a purchase of friendship by the mammon of unrighteousness. ‘ Gifts,’ says Hesiod, ‘ prevail upon gods and reverend kings.’ The abbe Bergier in the ‘ Dictionnaire de Theologie ‘ defines it as ‘ the offering up to God of an object which is destroyed in His honour, as a recognition of His sovereign dominion over all things.’ If we analyse this sentence closely, the underlying absurdity is apparent : how does the destruction of any object do honour to any person ? The abbe proceeds: ‘ It is not in the least anomalous for a poor man to make some slight present to a rich man who has done him a kindness ; he considers that, though his benefactor may not need the gift, still an expression of gratitude cannot fail to please him.’

There is, perhaps, a certain crudity in the notion, but with that we are not concerned. Here in the eyes of most critics is the root idea of sacrifice. Its principle is that man behaves towards divinity as he would towards one or more persons endowed with powers vastly superior to his own—potentates whose aid it were ill to seek with empty hands.

If it were true that the gift-sacrifice was the primitive form of sacrifice, it would also be necessary to prove that peoples on a lower plane of religious belief regard the superhuman and mysterious beings, upon whom they conceive themselves to depend, as men writ large; that is to say, as personalities subject to the same limitations and frailties as man, but gifted with higher or more active faculties. In that case, we should find them treating those beings precisely as their experience has shown it advisable to treat the grandees of this world, to wit, the priests and chiefs. Now, the etiquette observed by every non-civilised race forbids a man to approach his chief without a present. This constitutes the propitiatory sacrifice. If he has received a favour, he shows his gratitude by a fresh gift, and this may be called the sacrifice of thanksgiving. Or he thinks the chief is displeased, and to appease him, offers a sacrifice of pacification or expiation.(2)

All the above is true, but it is true only of a comparatively recent period in the history of mankind. You know what is understood by the doctrine of evolution. It is the knowledge that all things are in motion, and subject to a slow transformation governed by certain determinable laws. One of the axioms which should guide the sociologist who accepts this doctrine is that our modern ideas, because they are modern, cannot have been the ideas of primitive man, but must have been evolved from his by a gradual process of transformation.

Now the theory which considers sacrifice as a gift made to the divinity—the divinity being regarded as an immortal and therefore trebly formidable man cannot hold good for the beginning of things, for it still dominates the superstition of to-day.

Open one of the recent books—the ‘ Chinoiseries Romaines ‘ of Stheno, the ‘ Cordicoles ‘ of Tery, the ‘ Dossier des Pelerinages ‘ of Noel Parfait, or the excellent articles published in the Semaine Religieuse by the abbe Hemmer—and you will find that the essential character of present-day devotion, say the cult of Saint Anthony of Padua, lies in the idea of exchange — of gif-gaf. ‘ Good Saint, let me pass my examination, let me find my umbrella and I will give you, according to the state of my purse, a hundred francs or a hundred sous. You may even have them in advance, if that will weigh in my favour.’

Gentlemen, I do not say that this is either good or bad, childish or reasonable ; we are students, not tractarians. But, without leaving our own times, observe that, besides these sacrifices consisting of gifts or fines—privations which the believer inflicts upon himself— religion contains another and far more mysterious rite, hard for the non-elect to understand : I mean the so-called Sacrifice of the Mass. The salient features are these. The priest, impersonating the community, absorbs, under the form of bread and wine, the flesh and blood of the deity in order to impregnate himself with the divine essence. At intervals the faithful are allowed to participate in this sacrifice ; but since the Middle Ages, from motives of pure expedienc}’, only the bread is given, not the wine.

I have no sympathy with the sceptic — Voltairean he calls himself—who jests at this solemn and ancient rite ; he would be much better occupied in studying its origin and development. The question whether the godhead is or is not present in the host is not a scientific question ; the answer in the affirmative is only an opinion, and admits of no discussion. The problem we have to solve is this : Why, in the religion of to-day, are there two forms of sacrifice—one of the earth earthy, quite clear, and universally intelligible (I refer, of course, to the gift-sacrifice) ; the other obscure in the extreme, shrouded in mysticism, and so peculiar in its character that the communicant himself is none too sure what he is doing ?

If we concede the theory of evolution, it is certain that the straightforward sacrifice by gift must be a recent growth, while conversely the perplexing sacrifice of the deity himself must date from a past correspondingly remote. But it may be asked, how can the sacrifice of the Mass be older than the other, when the Mass was instituted less than two thousand years ago, whereas the Greeks, Romans, and Egyptians knew and practised the gift-sacrifice three or four thousand years before the birth of Christ ?

That is precisely the fallacy. The Egyptians, Greeks, and Romans were highly civilised nations, and therefore, like ourselves, cognizant of the gift-sacrifice. But, though distinctly reticent on the subject, they were also acquainted with the more mystic type, and aware of its extreme antiquity.

Moreover, a nation may have lived two thousand years before another and yet represent a more advanced stage of civilisation. Take an Australian savage of the present day, and compare him with one of those Greeks who, twenty-five hundred years ago, created the beautiful monuments of Athens. Which of the two is the primitive man ? Which of the two would have the more rudimentary—the more primeval—notions on religion ? The savage, obviously. The savage, then, is our principal witness ; and for the last hundred years he has been cross-examined with the utmost care. Now this is what happens. An Australian aboriginal tells you a strange tale. He says, for example, that he is absolutely forbidden to eat a certain animal, because that animal is his ancestor. This is surprising enough at first ; but, if you are a reader, you remember that the Greeks, the Egyptians, and the Hebrews have all testified to similar beliefs lingering among them as vestiges of the past — survivals as the moderns have it. You conclude then that the existing savage resembles a bed of limestone cropping out in an alluvial country. If we dig to a sufficient depth under the gravel, we strike the same limestone again ; and analogously if we delve far enough into the history of civilisation, from three to five thousand years before Christ, we rediscover our savage’s articles of faith.

Thus, the twentieth-century savage enables us to catch a glimpse—or more than a glimpse—of the opinions of our far-off ancestors, members of races that ripened earlier into civilisation, but nevertheless passed through the phase in which the savage still remains.

To return to the gift-sacrifice. If it were a primitive conception, then the lowest strata of savage humanity would exhibit two phenomena : firstly, the belief in one or more gods after the pattern of men ; and, secondly, the existence of priests acting as representatives and treasurers of the god. For without the priest there is no gift-sacrifice ; a pair of visible hands is always necessary to receive the offering in lieu of the unseen God.

But the case is not so. On the contrary, the most primitive religions know neither a personal god made in the image of man, nor a priest, the deputy of that god.

The Bible might be quoted as an exception ; but if from the very beginning the Bible assumes a personal god, it knows nothing of the priest. The priest is a latecomer in the history of Israel. And as for the anthropomorphic deity of the Pentateuch, he is barely older than the year 1000 B.C., the earliest date to which the present version of Genesis can be attributed. A millennium before Christ is little more than the day before yesterday—and the proof is easy. We all know now that there was a long period in the history of man when he knew neither metals, domestic animals, nor cereals. Now the redactor of Genesis is so comparatively recent a person that he had no inkling of any such period : Adam tends the trees in the garden of Eden, and, immediately upon his expulsion, betakes himself to agriculture, as though men from the first must have been familiar with fruit trees and cereals. Therefore the writer to whom we owe the biblical Genesis is modern, and his idea of a man-like god cannot be primitive.

On the other hand, the animal—or animal-headed — deities of Egypt carry us back to a much earlier epoch, anywhere between 5000 B.C. and 6000 B.C. Thus we may plausibly conclude that long before the divinity was invested with human traits he was envisaged under the form of certain animals.

And now comes a striking coincidence. Go to the most primitive of modern savages and you find a religion to which the man-god is unknown, and the animal or plant god all in all. It is not an individual animal or plant which they adore ; it is a particular species—animal or vegetable—the members of which they imagine are bound to themselves by a mysterious and immemorial tie. These, to their minds, are the protectors, the talismans, of the tribe or clan. More than this, they are apt to persuade themselves that they are lineal descendants of the guardian animal or plant, and proceed, logically enough, to adopt its name.

For instance, certain North American Indians call themselves Beavers. They hold that their ultimate ancestor was a beaver, who miraculously brought forth a man; they will not pass a beaver without some token of respect or attachment; and they are fertile in anecdotes of beavers who saved their lives—beavers who showed them fords—beavers who did them all manner of services.

From time to time, primitive peoples, addicted to the cult of animals, indulge in a peculiar type of sacrifice. Suppose that a tribe is afflicted with famine, drought, or an epidemic ; it argues that, for some reason or other, the mascot—say, the beaver—has withdrawn its countenance and protection. To effect a reconciliation, two methods will be employed. On the one hand, the tribe will offer gifts—in other words, carry food—to its tutelar animal : this is the gift-sacrifice. At other times the remedy is more eccentric. The first step is to convene a grand synod of tribal chiefs ; then a beaver must be caught and killed; and, finally, every man present eats a portion of its flesh. The point of this ceremony is supposed to lie in the fact that it is a sort of self-deification, inasmuch as it directly increases the element of divine energy inherent in every man. In a word, it is a savage sacrament, resorted to in supreme moments of distress or peril—a communion in which the sacrifice of a divine object imparts divinity to all that eat of it.

The great discovery of Professor Robertson Smith, of Cambridge, who died there at an early age in 1884, has shown that sacrifice by communion was older and more primitive than the sacrifice by gift ; that it was, in fact, the oldest form of sacrifice ; that traces of it are found among the Greeks and Romans as well as among the Hebrews ; and, lastly, that the communion in Christian churches is only an evolution of this primitive sacrificial rite. The communion did not originate with Christianity. On the contrary, it was a time-honoured and widely prevalent institution, especially among the half-civilised communities of Asia, where it had a great vogue with the lower classes, as the more enlightened section of the population had been won over to the simpler idea of the gift-sacrifice. To-day, then, we may call it a survival—a survival from the very childhood of the world. And here we have a perfectly satisfactory solution to two problems: firstly, why this extraordinary form of sacrifice should have taken so firm a hold on the better half of mankind; and, secondly, why its primary significance should have been so obscured both in the Middle Ages and in our own generation. In the first case, it gained ready and rapid acceptance because man was predisposed in its favour by his own religious past; and in the second, its import has been easily obliterated because it corresponds to an idea as far removed from modern modes of thought as a primitive chip flint from a Lebel gun.

Even yet we meet with the notion that when two men take food together a kind of moral and physical bond is established between them. Originally this idea was still stronger ; but only sacred food could knit the sacred tie. Nothing but the flesh of the holy animal would serve, and the solemn mystery of its death was justified in the sight of the faithful by their conviction that so and not otherwise must the mystic bond between the believer and his god be created and confirmed. Thus all there was of a higher life in the primitive community was bought by the death and periodic sacrifice of a god.

And now let us try to outline the evolutionary process which fused this primitive type of sacrifice with that of sacrifice by gift. When once agriculture and the domestication of animals had dispelled the mystery surrounding the different forms of plant and animal life, familiarity began to breed contempt. Little by little the idea of a divinity hedging certain species of animals faded away, and man began to create the godhead in his own likeness.

Yet there remained a tradition of animals sacrificed and eaten by the community. Therefore both sacrifice and banquet were retained, in the belief that the godanthropomorphic now—smelt the blood and inhaled the smoke of the burnt-offering. To provide him with a representative, a priest assisted at the ceremony, until in the end he and his ritual completely dwarfed the part played by the body of the faithful, and, while the sacrifice and banquet still survived, their significance was wholly inverted.

Gentlemen, I stop here. The question is difficult enough without my proceeding to pile problem upon problem. The point which I wished to bring out is this : that in primitive sacrifice the idea of communion—however modem it may appear at the first glance—is a factor of prime importance. The English scholar, who first discerned this truth, literally revolutionised the study of religion. He built, so to speak, a solid bridge between our own day and those dim ages when man bowed down and adored the beast. And this he accomplished by throwing into its proper perspective the primitive and strangely persistent conception of the god-animal, fated to be slain and eaten by its worshippers. I venture to think the discovery involves so much and has found so little recognition that you will pardon me for having made it the subject of these remarks.

(1) Lecture given in Paris, 1902, at the Universite populaire, rue Richer.

(2) Goblet d’Alviella, Revue dc runiversitc de Bnixelles, 1897-S9,
pp. 499-500. I have more than once borrowed textually from this excellent article.