Blast From the Past: ‘Judge Rules Against UCG Stalker’

King County District Court
East Division, Redmond Courthouse
Court Room #1
Date: September 15, 2004  10:05 AM
Judge: David Steiner Presiding
Case #: 047-035220

Video

Plaintiffs: Richard and Jo Briley
Accused: Arthur Dwyer

Charge: Stalking
Plaintiffs seeking injunction

Participants:

J:       Judge David Steiner
JB:    Mrs. Briley, Plaintiff
RB:   Mr. Rick Briley, Plaintiff’s Husband and co-plaintif
AD:   Mr. Art Dwyer, Accused
CA:   Mr. Carl A. Anderson, Witness–UCG Deacon
JBg:    Mr. Jerry Berg, Witness–UCG Deacon
SB:    Mrs. Sharon Berg, Witness–Wife of Mr. Jerry Berg

UCG: United Church of God, International Association

Transcript

J: OK, one of the concerns that I have initially is that the, uh, petitioner alleges that there are mental health issues, uh, that Mr. Dwyer suffers from and so I need to know exactly, uh, well maybe exactly is not the right word, I need to have some idea of Mr. Dwyer’s ability in handling himself in this hearing. Uh, Mr. Dwyer, do you understand what has been requested?

AD: Yes, your honor, I do.

J: And you understand that what the petitioners report shows that she has been unlawfully harassed by you and that the harassment in this case she alleges is an inappropriate attachment she alleges you have developed toward her and that attachment has exhibited itself in a number of behaviors including letter writing, uh, not letter writing–but communications made to her, even communications via third parties which were apparently her church, former church, perhaps current church, so you understand what she had to show?

AD: Yes, your honor, I do.

J: And here she’s able to show that her will has been ordered is that you have no contact with her.

AD: I can’t hear out of one ear, your honor.

J: Which one?

AD: This one here… It’s kind of clogged up.

J: All right, I’ll tell you what, I’m going to have everybody trade places, so Mr. Dwyer, I’m going to have you sit at that table and we’ll let you sit on the end chair there, and we’ll have your good ear facing me, so we can switch right now…. Sir you can kind of tilt your chair–yup, that’s right.

AD: OK.

J: So the question I have is, you understand that she’s required to show that harassment and do you have any questions about what I will do if she does show the harassment?

AD: No, your Honor, I don’t.

J: Do you have any questions about this hearing? About the process? Anything to do with what we are doing today?

AD: No, your Honor, I don’t.

J: And Mrs. Briley, do you have any questions?

JB: Your Honor, Judge Howard suggested that we could revisit the original hearing to make like three different changes to it and one of them adding my husband–he wanted to be added, but he couldn’t be present that day…

J: OK.

JB: So, we wanted him to be included in the order as protected also.

J: Well, I’m going to add him in by your motion as a party. He should have been included on the original order, he made the request. Let me just ask before I do that, actually, Mr. Dwyer, are you surprised by this request that Mr. Briley be added as a party you cannot contact.

AD: Your Honor, to put it mildly, yes.

J: Did you see that his name was on the original request?

AD: It was crossed off in the original.

J: Why does it surprise you that he might be now a petitioner.

AD: Why does it surprise me, Your Honor, that he might be a petitioner? Well, I would imagine because he is her husband–she’s his wife.

J: That’s right. So, you wouldn’t be surprised for that reason.

AD:  For that reason.

J: All right. So any reason you why feel you can’t.. aren’t prepared today you aren’t prepared to answer the request today that Mr. Briley be included.

AD: Your Honor, I don’t know how to answer that, since I don’t have a… well, if Mr. Briley desires… I’ll put it like this… no matter, well… I have no objections. I have no objections, Your Honor.

J: Well, let me indicate that it is extremely unusual for a family member not to be included in a petition, if they are resident in the same home, normally all family members would be included.  So, the motion to include Mr. Briley is granted. Any other questions from the petitioner?

JB: In the original hearing with Judge Howard, she, when I was told I could only put down to restrict the respondent from being 500 to within 500 feet, she said, “Why not put 1,500?”, and I said that would be great. And so she told me 1,500 and I was supposed to tell the clerk out there, and I forgot.

J: OK, well, you know what? That might not matter, since, unfortunately, sometimes you come before a judge and the judge just has a policy. Well I do. And it’s 100 yards, unless there’s some other indication.  And let me tell you why: The reason for the 100 yard policy is that often it’s very hard for people to calculate in their head what the other distances are, and the order then, can become quite unenforceable. Somebody comes within 1,400 feet and just proving they were within 1,400 feet can be very difficult. So I think that a number that people can know a football field, generally. And so, the 100 yards, I think, makes orders more enforceable, which is why I stick to the 100 yard distance. So it’s right now says 500 feet, it’s likely I’ll reduce it, if I grant the order, to 100 yards. Any other questions?

JB: We wanted to–if it asks for how long–why we don’t it just a year–we want it… for.. apparently a computer will not accept indefinitely, so I was advised by an advocate to ask for 25 years, and I would like to that.

J: And again, I generally don’t issue orders for that period of time and it’s not that the computer will not accept them, it’s that records over a period time, tend to grow old, people tend to wonder, they can get lost, people tend to wonder, “Does that record exist?”. And to make orders more clear and therefore more enforceable, I usually limit my orders to–if I grant them more than a year–to 5 years. And you can come back two months before the order’s to expire and you can request the order be reissued and it is then, if the order is issued, it is then Mr. Dwyer’s responsibility–his burden–to show why the order should not be reissued.   So, sir, you have raised your hand?

CA: Yes, Your Honor. I guess, since I don’t know the Brileys, but I do know Arthur, I was here to support him, in fact this has gone on for about a year, I guess….

JB: Seven years.

J: A little debate about what how long it has been going on…

CA: What I’m saying is, I’ve been with Arthur now for a year, and I have not heard or had any indication that he still has a problem with Mrs. Briley, and knowing him, he’s been in support groups….

J: OK, it sounds like you’re testifying, essentially, right now. We haven’t even started the hearing yet.

CA: OK, I guess, I’m not used to this myself, so I’m just trying to inject something because I’m not sure that Arthur really understands it.

J: OK, well, uh, we will hear the testimony from the petitioners and then, hopefully, he’ll understand what it is that they are saying.

CA: Thank you.

J: Who would like to like to testify first?

JB: Your Honor, I have, um….

J: Ms. Briley, by speaking, the answer’s yes, that you would like to testify first?

JB: Yes.

J: Would you raise your right arm? Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

JB: Yes, I do.

J: All right. What I would like you to do is, first of all, tell me,  how you know Mr. Dwyer, and then begin with the date that is most distant, that is, the first incident that you allege, and then working your way forward, tell me why you believe you have been harassed.

JB: Excuse me, I’d like to… I have… a note I wrote out here about violating the terms. I’ve know Mr. Dwyer for… well, I gave… I wrote this situation background, which has it all down here….

J: OK.

JB: If it would be useful to you. I thought it would be super.

J: How long is it?

JB: It isn’t as long as it looks because the last three pages are–this is actually a proposal that I offered to our church in 2000 to… after consulting with different agencies and passing by them and they thought this was a reasonable….

J: Why don’t you just testify? Why don’t you just testify to the incidents that have occurred?

JB: I’ll do my best.

J: OK.

JB: I have a lot of health problems that make my stamina and my ability to think on my feet a little bit… you know, very challenged, myself.

J: Why don’t you hand the document to the court then? The court will make copies. We’ll hand out the to both. What I am going to you ask is, who wrote that document?

JB: I did.

J: And is it all true and correct?

JB: Yes, Your Honor.

J: All right. So, while we’re getting copies, perhaps you can give me an overview of why you think the order should be given.

JB: Sure. In… let’s see… in 2003, our attorney Jim Tomlinson, sent the respondent a letter, based on behaviors that he had had, and we made that a part of the original order, and do you have that there, Your Honor? There is another copy of it here, if you’d like.

J: I did see it.

JB: You did see an order.

J: It wasn’t an order, it was a letter.

JB: Excuse me, I mean, it was a letter. Excuse me. In fact, it was a letter in order trying to prevent to ever having to do this and be here today. And then, in the letter,  the letter lists, it lists all the things that respondent has been doing and that have been very troubling things. We actually started in about ’96 or ’97. I was trying to place it. It’s kind of hard to place it. I think it has been about at least seven years that this has been going on at different levels.

J: So, the question apparently presented by one of the friends of Mr. Dwyer is, hasn’t this stopped over the last year?

JB: I’m sorry, Your Honor I didn’t….

J: Hasn’t this stopped in the last year?

JB: Hasn’t it stopped? No it has not.

J: What has happened in the last year?

JB: OK. I could give you a copy of this while I give you that run down of the timeline, if you like.

J: Why don’t you give me the last year?

JB. OK. OK. OK. The attorney letter was sent to respondent June 30, 2003. On July 11, respondent phones the petitioner’s attorney, our attorney, and tells Mr. Tomlinson that he has only one question, and that is, “Is this letter a court order?”. That’s his only question. And Tomlinson relates–“I told him”–this is a quote from Tomlinson now, our attorney, “I told him it was not”–not a court order–“that it was a letter from me advising him in no uncertain terms that must be no further contact with you”–meaning me, the petitioner, “I told him that if the terms of the letter were violated, a formal restraining order would be immediately obtained. He said that he understood, and that if you,”–meaning me, the petitioner, “wanted no further contact, then he would not initiate any. He said that he would abide by the letter and that he considered the matter concluded. He then hung up.” OK. Between 2003 and 2004, the respondent has continued to engage in prolonged discussions about petitioner with non mental health professionals in his church, contrary to what elders have told us in the church that he would be instructed not to do, and the reason for that being, that, he has evidenced a lot of delusional behaviors to us and we consider this a psychiatric problem that should be discussed only with mental health professionals and when it is discussed with someone other than a professional who does not know how to deal with delusion, all it does is feed the delusion for the respondent and make things worse. So we especially requested, that he not be allowed. And in addition, it feels like a third party communication, anyway because word gets back to us that he’s been talking for hours, you know, about me and about his feelings about me–it gets back to us. So.

October, 2003, in the Fall, people in our church attend an eight day church convention, and within a week, of the 2003 annual eight day church convention–which we also refer to as “The Feast”, respondent is telling friends he is going to Hawaii to the Feast. There are many different Feast Sites around the world. Later on, it is said, within days of my husband’s and my leaving for the Feast to Bend, Oregon, within days, respondent has been–we discover–the respondent has been maintaining a motel with reservation at our Feast Site, in defiance of his pastor’s orders, at Motel 8, I believe.

J: I’m hearing gasps and comments from the respondent’s side that I’m not very happy with, so if I continue to hear that, the respondent will be found in contempt and anybody else will be removed from the courtroom.

JB: OK. Now, this conversation which we didn’t know was going on until November of 2003, but, in October, within of a week of traveling to the Feast, respondent confides in a friend that he is really planning to go to Bend for the Feast, despite his having told people he is going to Hawaii, and despite his pastor’s orders, and he’s even willing to forfeit plane tickets he has to Hawaii to do so. The friend who is deeply concerned about the situation phones us, or, excuse me, I phone the person later, but anyway, they didn’t phone us right away….

J: I’m going to interrupt. Unfortunately, I have four hearings, I have in custodies coming in about ten or minutes, so I’m going to ask that you sort of “fast forward” to the facts, rather than all the details.

JB: OK. I’m sorry, Your Honor.

J: That’s alright.

JB: This year… just a minute here now… this was, um… could my husband take over now? I’m getting kind of exhausted here. Thank you.

J:  Did he show up at the Feast?

RB: No he did not, Your Honor, but he was… we were… Sorry.

J: That’s all right. Do swear or affirm to tell the truth, whole truth and nothing but the truth?

RB: Yes, I do. The friend he was confiding in, Your Honor,  states that he basically up to the last minute of his plane’s departure for Hawaii it was real “touch and go”, he was not even sure that he was going to Hawaii–it took a lot of convincing for the respondent to actually go to Hawaii.

J: OK. May I just jump forward a little bit and ask, from your allegations, this has been going on for eight years–seven years?

RB. Seven.

J: Why have you decided now to comment?

RB: I’ll get to that in a minute, Your Honor. This year…

J: Well, if you wouldn’t mind… What happened that decided, that made you decide, this why you needed to come in.

JB: Could I answer that, Your Honor.

J: Sure:

JB: OK. So, what went on–this is like a memory of last year, just very quickly–what had to happen was an involvement of many ministers and the Feast coordinator, they had to do all this last minute try to block respondent from being in Bend, so they scrambled, and they were prepared to call the police or whatever, if he arrived in Bend and tell him he would not be allowed in–to attend there. Now, we had that in our memory, that it happened last year. OK. Now, this year, we created a paper trail of making sure that respondent’s minister–Pastor–told him, himself, that he was not to go to Alaska for the Feast this year–that’s the place where we planned to go. And… we asked….

J: And that’s coming up in October?

JB: In October. Yes, in fact, we’re to leave in a couple weeks now. And then we got a confirmation that his pastor–the respondent’s pastor–had indeed instructed him he was not to go to Alaska for the Feast. That was done… the confirmation for that was July 21st, 2004, that he would not be at the 2004 Feast. Now…. You can take over there, because you have the form….

RB: Your Honor, there’s a registration process to tell the Feast coordinator where you’re going and we had checked earlier in the year after the registration and the respondent was not on the Alaska Site. And then on August 8th of this year, I received a call from a person in respondent’s congregation who has overheard him talking about going to the Alaska Feast Site and he’s looking–he has his plane tickets–and he’s looking for a rental car, and so to avoid the same problem as the last year at the last minute, shove back and forth, we contacted our minister, and he has sent us an e-mail saying that, talking to the respondent’s minister, he has been told not to go to Alaska, after already being registered for it.

J: So that was the incident that prompted this request?

RB: Yes.

JB: And, excuse me, Your Honor, there’s one more thing that happened: We delivered the original order, if you don’t mind, I think this might be really important… I think it is really important. Of course, everyone thinks that in court.

J: And maybe it is really important–I guess I won’t know until I hear.

JB: Thank you. On September 2nd, 2004 we delivered the order to the North Precinct where respondent lives. On September 3rd. And the police told us they would be trying to deliver it for the next five days–every shift, they would try. On September 3rd, 2004, petitioner was working on flowers on side of her residence, when a white compact car, matching the description of the respondent’s vehicle, pulls into their parking area and sits there perpendicular to parked cars….

J: And I would ask… I see you are looking at the respondent when you say that, so I would as you not to do that.

JB: I’m sorry, Your Honor. OK. This white compact car pulls into their parking–our parking area–and sits there perpendicular to the parked cars, and in a fire lane, directly facing their unit.

J: Why do you think it’s the respondent?

JB: Nothing happens for several seconds, until suddenly, the car backs up rapidly, and the car–the person in the car–did not come to drop anybody off, they didn’t drop anybody off, they didn’t pick anybody up; the car backs up rapidly, shoots forward to the stop sign on the main road, and accelerates rapidly into a left turn lane almost impacting a van and causing its driver to honk wildly. OK.

J: And that was when?

JB: That was September 3rd.

J: And that was where?

JB: That was right at our residence.

J: Just in… tell me again–where you think the car parked? Stopped?

JB: It pulled into our parking area, but perpendicular to parked cars, so, even though there were spaces, where it could have parked–where there were empty spaces….

J: Most people don’t have a parking area. Most people have a driveway and then they have a place where they can park by the side of a street. Do you have a parking area?

RB: Your Honor, it’s a small parking lot. It has four parking units or spots on each side, then there’s a curb on the front, where it’s a no parking area–that’s where the cars….

J: Is that a condo?

RB: Yes, a townhouse.

J: OK. OK. And the reason you think it was the respondent?

JB: It was certainly suspicious acting. You know, I mean to, ah. Also….

J: Well, OK.

JB: The police got upset with me for not reporting it right away. They got very upset.

J: Why do you think it was the respondent, other than this car did this?

JB: I think it is the kind of thing he would do….

J: You don’t know who that car belongs to?

RB / JB: Yes, we do!

JB: And that’s what I am saying: It was a car matching the description of the respondent….

J: OK. That’s one reason you think it was the respondent’s.

RB / JB: Yes.

J: The car matched the description….

RB / JB: Yes.

J: And… what… give me a little more description?

JB: OK, well, it was a white compact car.

J: OK.

JB: And we know he had a white Toyota–a small car….

J: OK, thank you.

J: Sir, can I have you raise your right arm.

AD: Oh. Ah. Excuse me, Your Honor.

J: Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?

AD: Yes, Your Honor, I do.

J: All right. Do you have any response to what has been said?

AD: I’d rather not give my response, Your Honor… I just don’t want to use language like that….

J: Well, most people–if they disagree with someone–can give a response without poor language.

AD: All right, I just won’t use poor language. I’ll just say I disagree with her.

J: That’s it?

AD: Thank you, Your Honor.

J: Sir! Do you have an infatuation with Ms. Dwyer?

JB: Ms. Briley.

J: Sorry.

AD: Your Honor, do I have an infatuation? No, Your Honor, I don’t.

J: Did you used to?

AD: Yes, Your Honor, I did.

J: When did it end?

AD: Ah… I’d rather not get into the details of it, but I could give you the details of it, if you want.

J: I do.

AD: All right. I met the ah… I met Mrs. Briley back in… I ah… I remember her in church, you know. I was on the sound crew, when they put this cute woman in the balcony.

J: OK. The details that I asked for were the details of when the infatuation ended.

AD: The detail of… ah… we broke up in May of 1996.

J: OK. And very briefly, how long did you have a relationship with Ms. Briley?

AD: Let’s see. I met her in… ah… uh… April 1991, and we broke up in May of 1996.

J: OK. And, since then?

AD: Since then. Uh. Well. Let’s just say I wasn’t the most mental… mental….

J: Have you had any kind of a relationship with her since then?

AD: No, Your Honor, I haven’t.

J: Have you wanted to?

AD: Yes, Your Honor, I have.

J: And when did that desire to that relationship with her end?

AD: It ended when I got the letter from Mr. Tomlinson.

J: And how did it end then?

AD: Well, I looked at all the results of what I it was I was doing, everything. I was praying for her and everything, and this was the result I had to show for it. And I just washed my hands of this woman completely. I called up Mr. Tomlinson; I asked him, “Is this a restraining order?”, and he said, “Well, I wrote it”. And I said, “Well, I’m going to treat it as though it were a restraining order, except the Feast Sites”.

J: Let me just stop you for a second. I know that you have several people here with you, who may have wanted to testify concerning this whole issue. Let me just ask you, do any of you believe that Mr. Dwyer had a relationship with Ms. Briley, between 1991 and 1996? You do? And you believe that because?

J: Sure, come on up. Have a seat. Raise your right arm. Sir, do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?

JBg: Yes sir, I do.

J: Your name?

JBg: Jerry Berg.

J: I’m sorry, the last name?

JBg: Berg. B-E-R-G.

J: And Mr. Berg, do you know Ms. Briley?

JBg: Yes, I do.

J: And how do you know her?

JBg: I known them for a number of years, like 30 years or more, and my wife and I attended their wedding.

J: All right. And the reason you believe that Ms. Briley had a relationship with Mr. Berg that they were dating, because he referred to them breaking up in 1996 is?

JBg: Ah, he had an infatuation with her because she was helping him with his mental and other problems….

J: And that’s what….

JBg: I’m sorry?

J: And that was when?

JBg: Several years. I think. We were not in the area all the time, but it was from approximately ’92 to ’96.

J: So she was helping him. But the reason you believe they were dating is?

JBg: They were not dating. They were only friendly association because she was trying to help him with his problems. And she….

J: That’s not the question I asked you. The question I asked you was whether they had a relationship, and I guess I should have defined that. You took that to mean they knew each other. That’s not what I meant. Mr. Dwyer was fairly clear in that they had a romantic relationship, between 1991 and 1996, and broke up in 1996.

JBg: No, that wasn’t what he was referring to. They never had a romantic relationship. It was strictly a friend to friend relationship. He used the term “breaking up” in a manner that is not… that we would not use as “breaking up” being a “woman and a man”. So what he said “breaking up” he meant they did not see each other any more–no further relationship.

J: All right, thank you very much. Uh, sir, is there anything else you would like to tell me?

AD: Well, yes, Your Honor. Just to reaffirm, I have not had… I have never had, and do not have, any romantic feelings for this woman and I have NEVER had any romantic feelings for this woman, EVER.

 J: What was your infatuation with her; what was your infatuation with her, then?

AD: Well, as I found out the hard way, Your Honor, you can love a woman without being romantic with her. I found her up here and found no romance with her at all.

J: Well, I don’t think anyone is debating whether was any romance, the debate is whether you wanted to have a romantic relationship.

AD: No, Your Honor, I did not ever. It never even crossed my mind of her having a romantic relationship with her.

J: OK. Anything else?

AD: No, Your Honor, not at this time.

J: We seem to be going in circles, Mr. Dwyer. I seems very clear you had a romantic infatuation with Ms. Briley for a number of years.

AD: I beg your….

J: Sir, that’s the end now; I’m speaking and I’m going to issue an order. And I make it very clear to you, sir, that if you have any contact with Ms. Briley, in any manner, through third parties, through anyone else, You’ll be charged with a crime. The crime is punishable by a year in jail and a $5,000 fine. So the end is now, sir.

JBg: Your Honor.

J: Don’t get me wrong.

JBg: May I, respectfully…

J: Very quickly.

JBg: I don’t feel you have all the facts, sir.

J: Unfortunately, I’ve held the hearing, I had as many facts as I need. Someone like Ms. Briley should not have to look over her shoulder, all her life, worrying about what Mr. Dwyer is going to be doing, and it’s very clear–very clear–and it should be very clear to everyone in this courtroom, that Mr. Dwyer has had an infatuation with Ms. Briley for a number of years, and it appears that she was absolutely right to be concerned for her safety. After all, when someone has an infatuation with them, that just will not end, and is not willing to allow it to end, then one has to worry, what is that person capable of?  What are they going to do next? So, sir, I’ve held the hearing, I’m going to issue the order, I’m going to issue the order for five years. I want to make it very clear to you, sir, that any violation of this is going to be very, very serious. If you are in the same place–if you find yourself by accident in the same place as Ms. Briley–you must leave: Which means it should be very clear to you, that you cannot go to any of these Feast Sites she may be at. At this point I’m not going to require counseling, but that is something I might consider in the future. So–yes, sir?

JBg: He is in counseling with church elders and has made tremendous progress in the last year. It is not known by others… but he has made tremendous progress in this situation….

J: Do you tell me, sir, if you are aware of this, and you are aware of this infatuation, why doesn’t Ms. Briley have a right to an order that require he have no contact with her? Why shouldn’t she have it?

JBg: Because, he has no desire to have any contact with her.

J: Well then, there won’t be any violation of the order.

JBg: Does that mean this is for just this state or all states?

J: All states. Everywhere. I would presume that if he didn’t want to violate it in this state, he wouldn’t want to violate it in another state.

JBg: That’s true. Now, is there a way for us to appeal this decision?

J: Yes, there is, sir. You can get the information at the front desk.

RB: Your Honor, can I say something?

J: Yes.

RB: I have affidavits here speaking to our character. I have one from a lady who has gone through a similar experience with Mr. Dwyer. He has also stated to my wife to my wife seven or eight years ago….

J: I’ve already held the hearing. Now you can put those in the file, if you’d like, and they can certainly appeal.

RB: I was to be added on the list. I noticed you only said my wife.

J: The order will include you. I presume… do you have the closed orders?

Clerk: I do, after this, yes.

J: I’m going to have to draft the order, and that will take me a few moments.

JBg: May I approach the bench with a letter?

J: Sure. If you would like to file a letter as well, you may.

JB: But we haven’t seen it, Your Honor, and we have served the respondent, and we would like a copy of what ever that is.

J: Sure. You can have a copy with the order. I’m not going to consider things which have just been filed. I’ve already made my decision based on the facts which were presented here.

JB: We just wanted things in place in case there were such an appeal because we want them to… we feel they are very important support for everything for our character.

J: OK. I just want to say, the support you’re providing is appropriate. The opposition to this woman receiving the kind of security that she deserves after these years is inappropriate. Yes, ma’am, very quickly.

SB: Just one thing. He has not had–as they said–any contact with her since last June, in over a year. He does not want contact with her. So I still don’t understand.

J: Well, I’m sorry you don’t, ma’am. The point is, the fear that is based on years of his infatuation is enough for her to say, and for me to say, that if she was entitled to the order a year ago and she comes in now, she is not simply making this up, and saying that my fear–I have an unjustifiable fear, she has a justifiable fear, she has a right to the order now, even if he hasn’t tried to contact her in a year.

OK. If I could have you have a seat, for a little while, I will–apparently we’re going to get that order drafted. The advocate is going do that, so I am going to take my other cases now.

The Infamous ManPower Papers

American Religious Police State


 

In 1961 at the behest of the Armstrongs a “manpower committee” comprising 15 of the leading men of Ambassador College (AC) was formed. The noble purpose of this committee was to evaluate AC students-especially male students-and determine whether or not to employ them at AC or in the Worldwide Church of God (WCG) upon graduation. The Manpower Committee, however, quickly degenerated into a high-level gossip session in which a group of corporate misfits combined to destroy the reputation of numerous students whose only offense may have been intellectual resistance to the doctrinal intimidation and personal prejudices of AC/WCG officials while attending to their formal education.

Before any discussion of a student began, his picture was projected onto a screen. Then, as the members of this “spiritual jury” stared at the student’s image, each one of them divulged information – often given to them confidentially in private counseling sessions – gathered on the student. This information often included a student’s background, racial and genetic heritage, sex and dating problems, attitudes, and physique, in addition to biased personal assessments of a student’s potential worth to the organization.

Below Ambassador Report is reprinting a number of statements made in these manpower meetings that aptly illustrate the mentality of the Ambassador College administration in the 1960s. Little if any concrete evidence for the allegations, innuendos, or rumors in the following quotations was ever formally submitted, probably because it never existed. All students were tried in absentia and never given a chance to reply to the biased information disseminated in these meetings that sullied their reputations. Yet the essence of what was said in these meetings was carefully typed and distributed to several leading men at AC in Pasadena, the vice-chancellor of AC’s Texas campus, and AC’s Personnel Office. (In order to protect the identity and reputation of the students mentioned in the following statements, we will refer to all male students as “X” and to all females students as “Y.” We have gone to great lengths to delete anything that we felt could lead to the identification of a student.)

RACIST COMMENTS

“Like most Negroes he is reserved, timid, and not as warm and spontaneous as he could be…. Most of our Negro leaders are partially white and don’t have the normal dull mind of the average Negro.”

“X has a lot of ego. He is a Jew, and a Jew feeds upon applause, people appreciating him, living in the limelight, being a performer, so they are hard to convert-but once converted Jews can be the best instrument in God’s hands there is.”

“Mr. Meredith feels a lot of this apparent haughtiness and cockiness is the results of the English class distinction bred in him…. The English people tend to be that way…. The English do this naturally.”

“He is converted, yet like most Germans, is hard to love…. It is most imperative that we all get to know him.”

COMMENTS ON SEX PROBLEMS

“He has had a sex problem since he was ten or twelve years of age; and since he came to college he has been able to overcome it several months at a time, but continually lapses back into it.”

“He is all but a practicing homosexual, has a masturbation problem, and apparently is only here to protect himself from the draft.”

“He is starry-eyed, has a glassy stare when speaking, is hard to listen to because of his poor eye contact-this may be a result of excessive masturbation in the past.”

“X was disfellowshipped from the Church several years ago because of homosexual problems.”

“She comes from a mother dominated home, a pragmatic home, and she needs a ‘he man’ to solve her problems.”

“Y has an excellent I.Q. of 123, but is neurotic…. She is unbalanced, she has sex problems and has masturbated from the time she was about 12 years of age…. She had an affair with a man in the… Church. She doesn’t fit here, she is a wrong influence. She shows definite deep influence from demons.”

“She acts like a lesbian, but is not-her fear and dislike for men is a result of demon influence as well as the result of an affair she had with a man that discussed her with men. She and her family have consulted spirits in the past….”

“He often looks glassy eyed, is washed out, enervated, which is unusual because he works out with weights and is athletic…. It’s interesting-he gave an Attack Speech this morning on masturbation-people tend to attack most vociferously the very thing they are fighting.”

“And although we would not say he is a weird personality, he has a few, weird, creepy characteristics. Dr. Hoeh wondered if he doesn’t have mental sexual problems, that he may be an intellectual homosexual, not that he’s ever physically committed such an act, but does he think about [it] ? We need to sound him out and find out.”

“Y has had dating problems with the fellows, a strong sex drive, a record of instability…”

“He does confess to mentally fornicating with our girls every day of his life. Before he came into the church he used to masturbate twice a day-he is a sexual pervert in his mind. He has had demon problems….”

“X was also discussed as a possible man for the Sermonette List, but when we found he was also guilty of necking (though done very lightly), he was rejected from the Sermonette List…. Mr. Apartian had talked to X before and will talk to him again to find out whether this was a quick goodnight kiss or could be classified as petting.”

MARRIAGE MANIPULATION

“Mr. Smith said whoever counsels them in the final outcome should certainly write her father and tell him we will do all we can to discourage her marriage if he wants us to…. After further discussion we all feel best to advise them to throw cold water on it….”

“Mr. Meredith has already counselled him to postpone any engagement plans, primarily because Mrs. Armstrong was horrified when she heard about them.”

“The Manpower Committee saw no objections to a marriage sometime in June.”

“Mr. Hill said X had counselled him about marrying Y…. Dr. Hoeh did not feel, however, that she should tie herself down to him-she is a terrific girl, should be a Minister’s wife.…”

“Mr. Armstrong just recently made an ironclad rule that any Senior who wants to marry a Freshman is automatically out of college and if he doesn’t take that in a right attitude is out of the Church.”

“X and Y were making marriage plans when advised to put it in God’s hands, break off the wedding plans, and wait until a later date…. it is doubtful she can be sure she and X are actually in love.”

“Mr. Portune said he called the engagement between X and Y off-that he did not believe X was stable enough or ready for marriage.”

“Mr. Elliott brought up the problem of Senior men speaking for Freshmen girls a few weeks after they have arrived on campus…. We are not bringing girls to Ambassador College to marry Senior students after only being here a month or two-we are bringing them here to train them to be wives and mothers, which should mean at least two years at Ambassador College.”

“X was going steadily with Y until Dr. Hoeh counselled him to consider marrying a Russian…. Mr. Portune brought out, however, that he had counselled them and told them that they could not get married for a year and a half after graduation and they both know that they cannot get married…. These students need to learn that unless God is with them they have no business getting married in the first place…. Let’s give them the test, make them… quit running from one minister to the next… and wait the year and a half after graduation as Mr. Portune told them to do in the first place…. Take the emphasis off sex and marriage and get it on the desire to seek the Kingdom of God.”

“Y and X are in love, but they were told they must not get married until the Feast of Tabernacles, 196- [1½ years after this was written]. This will be quite a trial on both of them.”

“He has effeminate tendencies and is definitely a fringer. We need to tell him we don’t want to live his fife, but we advise him not to get married-that the marriage will not work….”

“Now Y is over there and she is getting romantically involved with a weak student named X. His stock is weak. If we were cattle raisers we would not begin to allow such mating to take place. Breeding is very important.”

“X is too close to Y, we need to break them up-either he goes or she goes. He is too polished, he needs Texas [Ambassador College’s Texas campus), he needs to get a little manure under his fingernails….”

“He is interested in Y…. Mr. Apartian mentioned being disappointed with both of their attitudes, because he told them to break it off-but she loves him…. She is sanctimonious, like he is, and we only have eight years left anyhow [8 years till 1975, the year the WCG predicted Christ would return].”

“Mr. Portune… says he [X]… is a clod… a clown in the eyes of the other students, a prolific eater-eats everything in sight. X is only $15 in debt. He wants to marry Y. She… comes from good stock, is a nice-looking girl, beautifully shaped, and is only $438 in debt. Mr. Hill [said X]… has an odd approach, hasn’t produced, and can’t identify himself with the problems. He is like an unemotional fish and needs to attack something and get stirred up. Mr. Blackwell wondered then if it might not be best to… separate he and Y for awhile… and let him know this is it-sink or swim.”

“Dr. Zimmerman… counseled him… to put cold water on his plans with Y…. During the past summer he was sent to… look for work, primarily to separate he and Y…. He later came back to ask Dr. Zimmerman to ask again for approval to get married. Dr. Zimmerman told him again to throw cold water on it…. X felt he could…. Dr. Zimmerman doesn’t feel any consideration should be given him toward marriage, that he should be told again to put cold water on it. Mr. Meredith said he should be told not to even think about marriage for one or two years at least”

GENERAL COMMENTS

“X is odd, he came to talk to Mr. Meredith about his inability to sweat in prayer, after Mr. Meredith’s sermon on really putting your heart and all your being into prayer….”

“X was told he must lose five pounds a month.”

“X is also odd, finky, but has a good mind…. He has been too steeped in music….”

“He was recently given a lie detector’s test which shows him to be a liar and a thief, but since the test is not infallible, and he staunchly maintains his innocence, we cannot be sure that he is a thief and liar. The lie detector records only conscious thought, however, and he was grilled for more than eight hours….”

“X is… very hard to get to know-there is always a question in our minds as to what is going on in his mind.”

“X… has had a perpetual health problem (constipation).”

“Y is weird; she is not normal; she is extremely neurotic. We wouldn’t be surprised if she didn’t someday try to destroy herself….”

“Some of the students just had a big party at which they played questionable music, with a wrong beat, drank too many beers, got involved in the wrong kind of dancing….”

“Mr. Meredith, when reading about the wretched background he [X] came from, added that X’s mother and father get in real “knock-down-and-drag-out” fights, get involved in sexual perversion, and have a wretched relationship. She has a Pentecostal background.”

“Mr. [Ted] Armstrong read the resume for X and the comments made at previous Man-Power Meetings-with the comment that X is an ‘ass.’… Being an ass is no condemnation, it is far better to be an ass than to be effeminate, a weakling, or a problem.”

“Mr. Garner Ted Armstrong opened the meeting…. Mr. Armstrong further stressed the need for pooling our information from both colleges [Ambassador College’s campuses in Pasadena and in Big Sandy] by receiving their [man-power] notes for graduating seniors and supplying them with ours.”

“Mr. Armstrong could see no reason why they should not get married. His future is already mapped out for him.”

“He is somewhat boyish… having been reared without a man in the house, and has taken on many womanish ways-although we don’t feel he is effeminate.”

“After the previous Man-Power comments were read on X, it was brought out that he is a product of his environment. Richard Plache said his father is extremely odd, a character, is self-righteous, egotistical, and is a constant problem. Like his father, he goes to bed at night wanting to die…. he has a clinging, fishy handshake, showing complete lack of strength, character, etc…. Mr. Meredith explained the need for all of us, as Man Power Committee members, to get beneath the veneer of these men and fully know their problems….”

“Mr. Meredith… said… he is dull…. Richard Plache added… that… X’s parents have the same slow, dull, sluggish ways In fact, he has a younger brother who is far worse than he is-is much more buffoonish , duller, and has almost no life or spark at all. Mr. Portune feels… we could send him out for a trial as a warm body… to the minister and assist the minister in some of the routine visits.”

“Mr. Armstrong read the previous evaluations of X which included comments on his family background…. He is in love with Y and they eventually want to get married. Mr. Armstrong found it a little hard to understand a mutual attraction between them…. He is sincere and he assures us he really loves Y and that there is a mutual physical attraction as well as the intellectual. Most of us might not find her attractive because of her thick wrists and ankles and blocky build….”

“Mr. Armstrong said the Admissions Committee needs to be more strict and forceful in turning down people who have physical handicaps”

“Y is not a very pretty girl, she is not a great intellect, but she will make someone a very fine wife.”

“Neither Mr. Armstrong nor Mr. Meredith feel that this is the right girl for X; she is a peasant-type girl, is slightly dumb and immature.”

“Mr. Hill… says there are no problems except for a few effeminate flareups now and then, a womanish tendency, but he does have good dignity, a good mind….”

“He is a liar, a fink, a queer, and has lost job after job.”

“X has a self-righteous attitude. He… has a semirebellious attitude… is another one of those whom we cannot seem to get to know.”

“He continues to show disrespect for authority, talks disparagingly of the leaders of the work over the breakfast table… has many signs of hidden rebellion. His children are constantly on the spanking list at school…. He is a dirty player, fouls others continually.”

“X appears to have a bad attitude some, or most of the time. The whole attitude of that family has never been too good.”

“We need to get to know X and jar him into cooperation….”

“X is weak, effeminate, unable to rule his house and unable to master his marital problems”

“He is slow, dull, unable to think, and is all but completely lacking in zeal.”

“X is a hard worker, but he doesn’t seem to know his own mind.”

“She had a breakdown in Mr. Buzzard’s class the other day-she couldn’t stop crying. We don’t want ‘odd’ people-people obviously demon influenced. We should not hesitate to kick her out at the end of this semester, unless there is a drastic change.”

“He is not emotionally unstable as girls normally are, nevertheless, he does have an emotional problem.”

“X is still somewhat girlish, although not queer; he lacks the strong masculine quality. He has a weak voice like Richard Nixon….”

“He did finally come to talk to Mr. Elliott, he told about kissing in the bedroom, where another student saw him, but he didn’t tell everything. He went behind the science class building, behind Mr. Meredith’s house, and fondled her breasts, etc., and she is the one who told this to Mr. Elliott.”

“Mr. Ted Armstrong said there are still security leaks in our manpower committee that must be stopped. Word got back to X that we had discussed him in a recent manpower meeting, but what he heard was 5th or 6th hand, perverted, warped, and only a small percent correct.”

“Unless he goes into the field [ministry], the draft may snatch him up. Someway we need to legally classify him as doing ministerial work of some nature. Mr. Hill classified X as an assistant to him, dealing with theological responsibilities, as a ministerial assistant, and he was reclassified without any problem. He suggests we write the same kind of letter he did to the draft board…. ”

“X took Y, W, V, Z, and the girls signed out to go to the Student Dance. Instead they went to a football game, and when it didn’t prove exciting enough they went to a park and played touch football themselves. Some other people joined the party… and they wound upgoing to the sister’s house of one of the people they met and staying till 2:30 in the morning dancing and drinking. When they brought the girls back they were fearful of getting caught so they dropped the girls off on Orange Grove Boulevard. The girls cut through the Orange Grove Manor property and signed in-but they falsified their time…. His father is cocky, conceited, has constant financial problems… is often bothered with demons, etc.”

“…the sewage of X’s activity continues to flow through to us He is one of the worst scum who has ever walked across this campus”

Ambassador Report feels that the manpower mentality still predominates at AC. Some have cited the discontinuation of the comprehensive Manpower Committee in 1970 as a sign that all is now well. However, a memorandum from the committee’s chairman, Gainer Ted Armstrong, indicates that there is still cause for concern:

“…it will be no handicap whatever for various departments to obtain useful information about prospective employees, or for a smaller group to make requests concerning prospective ministerial assistants….” (Memorandum to All Committee Members, Manpower, Jan. 8, 1970.)

Most of the men who made the assessments and final decisions in manpower meetings are still college administrators, student counselors, department heads, or policymakers for the general student body. They still advise and counsel students, becoming familiar with each student’s most intimate problems. Yet the mentality of many of these men remains basically unchanged to this day. It is painfully obvious from their sermons and articles that their positions of prejudice and disregard for students’ rights still exist, public pronouncements to the contrary. The reason these harmful prejudices still exist is because the mentality of “ministerial privilege” has never been significantly discouraged nor discontinued from private practice among Ambassador executives.

Ambassador Report feels that student and public awareness of AC’s disregard for its students’ rights is imperative in order to discourage further abuse by members of the administration. Also, we encourage all AC students to be aware that what they reveal to AC counselors and/or WCG ministers may one day be used against them or passed on to others.

A reliable source inside AC has informed us that one administrator currently secretly records his counselings with students and church members and later has the conversations typed by his secretary for future reference. In light of this report, we feel the need to notify all AC students of their legal right to complete confidentiality in matters of spiritual guidance and their right not to have their personal problems and identities divulged to AC or WCG officials for reasons of employment or any reason whatsoever.

California law clearly states that under no circumstance is a minister allowed to divulge or otherwise disseminate information supplied to him by an individual seeking spiritual guidance. Confidentiality is implied, and any breach of this confidence (especially for reasons of discrimination in employment) is prosecutable under the law.

Revisiting The Garnet Hill RIP-OFF!

Beware Ambassadors’ Bearing Gifts!

 


The letters below in colored print have been reproduced and added to this article.
-James.


Are you frustrated? Is your life in turmoil? Is your marriage a disaster? Are your finances in shambles? Are you turned off by the sham of popular religion? Are you nauseated by the phoniness that dominates today’s society? Are you seeking for answers? Are you now ready to get yourself involved in truly purposeful and worthwhile endeavor?

If your answer is, Yes, look out! You’re in dangerous territory. Your immediate decisions and actions could be extremely hazardous to your wealth, not to mention your future spiritual well-being

You are a prime candidate for suckerdom!

FATAL ATTRACTION

If you presently find yourself in the position described above (and don’t we all at one time or another in our lives?), you may possibly find yourself attracted to the television program that is presently at the top of the religious program charts: I refer to The World Tomorrow program.

Watch out! It could be a fatal attraction!

It is easy to see why this slick, well produced program would attract the attention of many people who are concerned about the present state of our nation, The World Tomorrow appears to offer solutions to the great questions of the day. If you call (toll free, of course) the sponsors or the program, the Worldwide Church of God (WCG) headquartered at Ambassador College, in Pasadena, California, they will graciously send you a free subscription to their monthly publication, The Plain Truth magazine. Upon request, they will also send you (“free” of course) vast collection of glossy publication on a multitude of religious and other topics, topics that will stimulate your mental processes and encourage you to seek the “answers” that are presently lacking in you life.

These “answers,” naturally, are only available from one source -”God’s one true church,” which conveniently happens to be the Worldwide Church of God.

Beware ‘Ambassadors’ bearing “free” gifts!

CO-WORKERS AND THE “GREAT COMMISSION”

Many recipients of this “free” material, impressed by its quality and apparent truthfulness, begin to feel guilty for not having paid for it.

They decide to “help out” by sending in a check.

By return they receive a letter of thanks addressing them as “co-worker’s in THE Great Work of God.” If they continue to contribute money, they receive lengthy “co-worker letters” extolling the alleged virtues of “the Work” and telling of the grandiose plans being implemented to “spread the gospel” still further afield.

With each passing “co-worker letter” it is heavily implied that the Great Creator God of Heaven and Earth has Personally led you into direct contact with His “one true church.” You should now “obviously” want to join the “select of the elect” (WCG), attend church services, and play your God ordained part in the fulfillment of the “great commission.” Obviously!

The ploy is subtle. It’s very attractive, It appeals to the ego. It seems to be logical and make sense, gives you a sense of “worth,” Who, after all, would be spiritually dumb enough to turn down the Creator’s direct and Personal invitation to become one of His “elect” and have “a part in His great end time Work”? Few indeed!

After all, who wishes to commit spiritual suicide?

AN ADDED BONUS

Stop! There’s more. As an added bonus, you are personally guaranteed that, in “the glorious and wonderful World Tomorrow,” you PERSONALLY will have a direct part in straightening out this sin sick world. Who could ask for anything more?

Heady stuff, this exclusivist religion!

TRUE BELIEVERS

Let’s face it! There is a great emptiness – a yawning void – in the hearts and lives of most people. This vacuum cries out to be filled!

But there is a problem! Most people have little interest in being free and independent. Such a prospect frightens them! Most have a burning desire to “belong,” to be part of the “in” crowd, to be where the “action” is. They want to hitch heir wagon to a “cause,” or to a religious or political guru – a leader who will at least lend a sense of purpose to their otherwise miserable existence. As a result, many are ripe to become “true believers” in a political or religious cause!

THE CHURCH WAS THEIR LIFE

hill

Mr. Garnet Hill of Miami, Florida, was one such true believer. In the early 195O’s and nearing retirement, Garnet and his wife happened to stumble across The World Tomorrow radio program. They were impressed. It seemed to be what they were looking for. They responded, and were later baptized Into the Radio Church of God later to become the Worldwide Church of God).

From the beginning the Hills were totally identified with its alleged purposes and goals. The church was their life!

Like all “good” church members, the aging Garnet Hill and his wife gave at least ten percent of their meager income’ to Worldwide Church of God. Every third year they gave an additional ten percent to the church for the sustenance of the widows and others in dire need, In addition to this horrendous financial burden, the Hills (like all “good” church members) repeatedly gave sacrificially as instructed by their new guru, “God’s one true apostle,” Herbert W. Armstrong. He always said the money was “desperately needed” to do “God’s Work.”

SELLING HIS LAND

In 1970, Garnet Hill (then in his late seventies and with his wife ill with cancer) responded in his usual whole-hearted manner to yet another of Armstrong’s urgent pleas for more money to keep “the Work of God” moving ahead.

In additional to his home, Hill owned six plots of land in Hollywood, Florida, valued at $35,000. In his zeal to comply with Armstrong’s relentless demands, Hill decided to sell the land and give the lion’s share of the proceeds to “the Work.”

The sale of the six plots was left in the hands of Armstrong’s local representative, Brent Curtis, and his assistants. Later, Hill was told that the sale realized $30,000, or $5,000 less than the land’s assessed value. Of this, Hill gave $20,000 to “the work.” He asked for $10,000 for himself, so that he could meet any emergencies that might arise in his old age.

NO RECEIPT

When, after a number of months, he had failed to receive a receipt for his generous donation Hill began to ask Curtis and Armstrong’s other agents in the Miami area for an explanation. Although his queries went unanswered, Hill was accused of being a trouble maker. He was told to “be patient.” He was also told he needed to “repent” of his “bad attitude.”

Hill was then ordered to “keep quiet” about the apparent theft of his $20,000. His reply was that it would be “a sin to cover up sin.”

FOLLOWING CHRIST’S ADMONITION

Four years later, Hill decided to follow Christ’s admonition in Matthew 18:15-17. On February 10, 1981. ins “personal” letter to Herbert W. Armstrong, he took his $20,000 problem to “headquarters” in Pasadena, California. Hill expected, in all good faith, that the problem would be immediately corrected.

On November 9, 1973, Bob G. Seelig of the accounting department at Pasadena “headquarters” had written Mr. Hill. Seelig stated that they had “checked all (their) donation records and other sources of information (and)… there seems to be no knowledge or record here of your donation.”

Three years and three months later, on February 14, 1977, in a letter from “the legal office at God’s work,” and signed by Benton Nesmith, Hill was informed that his funds had been somehow “mis-applied.” Nesmith went on to explain that “we recently succeeded, after a protracted effort, in obtaining $5,000.00 for the church. This represents a portion of the funds from the sale of your lots which were not sent to headquarters…”

[In the words of Neville Gilbert, a close friend of Hill, “the Pasadena crooks had apparently put the ‘heat’ to the Miami crooks, who had in turn come through with 25% of the stolen loot”].

This blatant admission of deceit and fraud was followed by a request that he (Hill) send the church the deeds to his remaining property. Also enclosed was information on how to bypass probate for savings accounts. The church obviously wanted all his savings when he died!

NO LONGER WELCOME

Late in 1981, Hill, now 87, in rapidly failing health and legally blind, received a phone call from Al Kersha, Armstrong’s new head man in Miami. Kersha was angry: “You are not welcome (at services). I am putting you out of the church for talking about it” (the theft). Hill later told friends that Kersha then slammed down the phone with such violence that it hurt his (Hill’s) ear.

Garnet Hill was devastated by his excommunication from Worldwide Church of God. He now found himself alone, with no family or friends. His former “brethren in Christ’ were forbidden to speak with him, for fear of being contaminated by his “sin.”

A few lay members in the Miami Worldwide Church of God congregation tried to give Hill moral support, phone calls etc. but feared to do more for him lest they, too, be excommunicated on orders from the Pasadena Pope.

The Armstrong cult has a diabolical grip on its adherents

NO MERCY AND COMPASSION

During the months following his excommunication Hill, broken, disillusioned, emotionally destitute, and now legally blind, cried out for help. Only one Worldwide Church of God deacon had the courage of his spiritual convictions. He heard Garnet Hill’s cry, and helped him.

TREATED WITH CONTEMPT

It would, perhaps, be logical to assume that “God’s true church” would respond, as Jesus did on similar occasions, with mercy and compassion. Wrong again!

Mr. Hill’s personal letter to “God’s one true apostle,” Herbert W. Armstrong, protesting his excommunication was treated with the same contempt that has consistently characterized the cult that has become known an ‘The Worldly Church of God.”

February 10, 1981

Dear Mr. Armstrong:

I was put out of the Church for TELLING THE TRUTH. I am 87 years old and can hardly see.

In 1970 I received your letter how bad the Church needed money. My wife
had cancer, and I didn’t have much cash. But I did own six lots so I gave
those to the church. The lots sold for $30,000. I got $10,000 and $20,000
was to go to the church.

I GOT NO RECEIPT.  I ask [ed] Mr. Curtis minister at the time and he said
don’t worry about it.  He kept telling me the same thing.  AFTER A LONG
TIME I wrote Pasadena about the $20,000.  They NEVER RECEIVED IT.

This is where my troubles started because I started asking what happened to the $20,000.  I WAS TOLD TO KEEP QUIET and told don’t talk about it.  You said it was a SIN TO COVER UP A SIN.  I HAVE BEEN MISTREATED BECAUSE I WOULD NOT COVER UP.

Last Penticost [sic] Mrs. Witte a church member ask me about the problem. I told her I felt terrible about the COVER UP.  She said I don’t believe a word you said.  The next day Mr. Kersha the new local minister called on the phone and said ‘You ARE NOT WELCOME, I am putting you out of the church for going around telling people about it.’  I was standing by the wall.  SHE CAME TO ME.  MR. KERSHA WOULD NOT LET ME TELL HIM TRUTH.  Mrs. Wittle sought me out I did not seek her.

My friends no longer call me. After Mr. Hill was disfellowshiped
Someone must have SPREAD EVIL ABOUT ME.  I am not the one who had
done evil.  Mr. Pearson a deacon, later promoted to elder has not liked me because I would not sell him my deceased wife’s rings for $700.  After I had already had them appraised for $1850 at House of Diamonds of Miami.  He got angry with me because I turned them into the church.  Mr. Armstrong I ask you WHO DID THE WRONG? . . . WHY HAVE ALL THE MINISTERS TREATED ME LIKE I WAS THE THIEF? . . . . Mr. Armstrong I am getting along in years and am angry and LONELY since being put out of the Church and TREATED LIKE A THIEF.

I want to know if you approve of the way I have been treated?  Please let me know. God knows the truth.

Mr. Hill’s “personal” letter to Armstrong was answered by Joseph Tkach, an Armstrong assistant, on April 9, 1981. Tkach fully approved of the cult’s mistreatment of Hill.

Dear Mr. Hill:

Your letter was forwarded to me by Mr. Hunsberger of the personal correspondence department. I have REVIEWED OUR FILES and received additional information regarding the background of your situation FROM OTHER PEOPLE IN OUR LEGAL DEPARTMENT AND MAIL PROCESSING CENTER. I feel I understand what happened.

Also, I have verified with Mr. Kersha the circumstances leading up to your being disfellowshipped. After all this review, my conclusion is that Mr. Kersha has performed this duty as God would have him to.

It is regrettable that the sale of your property was mishandled like it was, but you must come to realize that THE PEOPLE INVOLVED HAVE REPENTED of their wrong doing. When God forgives He forgets. YOU MUST LEARN TO DO THE SAME. Mr. Kersha has given you several warnings about talking against the ministry of the church. You shouldn’t have continued to harbor this ill will.

The action of being disfellowshipped is used to show you the gravity of your sin — unwillingness to forgive and forget. Upon PROPER REPENTANCE Mr. Kersha would be very happy to welcome you back to the church — with open arms. It’s my sincere hope that you will be able to return.

AWESOME HUMAN WRECKAGE

Shortly thereafter, 89-year-old Garnet Hill died. He was just one hideous example of the awesome human wreckage strewn in the wake of Herbert W. Armstrong in his diabolical lust for fame, fortune and raw power. There are tens of thousands more!

A few days prior to his death, Garnet Hill received his final letter from “God’s one true church.” No, the letter didn’t inquire about Mr. Hill’s health and spiritual well-being. No, it didn’t offer him spiritual or financial assistance. It asked if Worldwide Church of God was still named in his Will.

Nuff said!

And the moral of this true story? Beware ‘Ambassadors’ bearing gifts. The life you save may be your own!

___________________________________

Mr. Hill’s humble home can be found here.

letter1

letter2