My apologies to anyone who feels hurt by my title. It would have been safer for me to avoid this subject entirely, but I’m convinced that it matters a great deal. So, let’s get to it: The word “God” has become confusing, distracting, and counterproductive. It carries immense baggage, and it’s time we let it go.
Who can forget the senior banquet hosted by Herbert Armstrong for the Ambassador College Seniors? Before graduation, he wanted to expose the AC students to culture, replete with gold and silver place settings and fine crystal, accompanied later in the evening by Herbert Armstrong himself playing the piano — nocturne in e flat major op. 9 no. 2 by Frederic Chopin, was it? Everyone who saw the video at the Feast was so impressed. We were all impressed, that is, until we learned that Ross Jutsum ‘sweetened’ the playing by, well, playing the piece. It was just another one of those situations where Herbert Armstrong cheated. You know, like claiming to obey the Ten Commandments while committing incest with his daughter, being a chancellor of a college when he hadn’t even finished high school, paying 9.75 of his income as a tithe and having a donut and cup of coffee on the Day of Atonement while 95 year old widow ladies fasted and went without. It just seemed he had to cheat and ‘fudge’ everything and even got coconspirators to participate with him.
Herbert Armstrong was high on music — he said repeatedly that it had to be ‘melodic’, which, if you think about it, pretty much defines what music is. He liked to play ragtime on the piano in his youth and was fond of most classical music (except for that demon inspired stuff, like “Let me come in, let me come in!”). Yes, Ambassador College was a real classic and even had rather famous people come play in the Auditorium. He brought refinement to the community. Well, it was Pasadena, so what can we say? Have you seen downtown?
We’re not certain that the Worldwide Church of God membership really caught on, particularly during the days of Garner Ted Armstrong appearing on Hee-Haw and what with the popularity of Bluegrass in the Southern States. We’re not sure that the members really appreciated the finer aspects of culture in their life, but that may be because they had to give so much of their livelihood in tithes, offerings, building fund and Herbert Armstrong induced emergencies when he overspent in his manic mode… or perhaps drunken alcoholic sot, three sheets to the wind mode.
It’s time, of course to reach back in time and bring Armstrongists and former Armstrongists back up to speed by presenting a video about the history of classical music (unfortunately missing one of the most famous composers, P.D.Q. Bach):
“Ignoring science has led to the crumbling of society.”
If there is one thing you should take away from the video above, it is that “Ignoring science has led to the crumbling of society”.
Rome rejected science and slipped into the dark ages.
Society tends to declare war on science to serve Ideological Agenda.
Science is much more than a body of knowledge and applications. It’s a way of thinking; a way to unravel the world’s mysteries, to see its beauty, where we can look at all the facts to make informed decisions, instead of relying on preconceived notions and biases. Science doesn’t choose a political party, it simply adheres to evidence….
Remember that a vote for science is a vote for knowledge and progress, based in reality.
Michael F. Flynn wrote The Autumn of Modern Science in a guest editorial of the April 2016 issue of Analog Science Fiction and Fact in which he notes that ‘modern’ society is moving away from science and moving to the social realm — in other words, emotions and the way people feel are more important that observations and facts, ultimately leading to the ‘Autumn’ of science where science is relegated to a lesser role in making decisions and setting a course: “The thought-cliche for ‘good’ is now ‘sexy,’ and products are sold by buff men and women seldom wearing white lab coats.
Indistinguishable from magic
During the twentieth century, progress took on ironic overtones among elites. Post-modern made a sudden and dramatic appearance. “Urban” and “urbane” parted company, as did “artst” and “artisan.” This terminological ferment signaled the emergence of new ways of thinking.
What does all this mean for science in the coming age? Some bold forecasts:
As it becomes more important to feel than to think, the Scientist as Culture Hero will fade. Too many scientific findings, flaunted prematurely on the evening news, are questionable, wrong, or retracted. Science has become associated with pollution and other problems. The radicals and intelligentsia grow disenchanted.
People will still do science for the old reasons. But political funding will channel more and more research toward political goals. The perception of the scientist as a hired gun will grow — especially if standards of proof are relaxed or theories are accepted for their elegance and mathematical beauty. Having been in turn the Handmaiden of Philosophy, then of Engineering, science in the coming age will become the Handmaiden of Policy….
The result will be a “science-less science.” Lots of facts, rules of thumb, and heuristic models, but few insights into nature. But causal principles that are not known (“manifest” are hidden (“occult”).. And the manipulation of matter through occult powers is called “magic”.
And so the golden summer of science is sliding into Autumn.
However, within the Cult of Herbert Armstrong Mafia, it’s already winter time for science. It is cold and freezing. The winds are howling. There is a biting weather chill that scrapes the bone. Science has been rejected for magic and thus, sufficiently advanced science is indistinguishable from magic.
For the longest time, Dr. Herman Hoeh was the ‘hired gun’ to take science and history and deform them into the distorted perceptions requisite to support the End Time Apostle. He was a hired church cult corporate hack to churn out supporting ‘evidence’ for the pronouncements of the madness of the [false] prophet. He knew it was wrong, but he had a mandate to manufacture fabrications to impart credibility to the very daft kook, Herbert Armstrong.
To Herbert Armstrong, science was only a tool to wrench twisted paradigms into viable doctrines and he didn’t care if it was true or not, just so long as it supported his great swelling ego. It is all to gain an advantage to propel those in power to greater heights of power, money, control and influence — as well as conspicuous affluence.
Earth in Universe
Science is all about observation. Observation is the very last thing Armstrongist leaders want people to do. The leaders want their followers to believe what they tell them. What the leaders tell them is abject lies which are inimical to science. Science will disprove the doctrines of the Armstrongist Churches of God. The leaders do not want the followers to know. The leaders want their congregants to believe British Israelism. The problem is that the observations of the scientific method demonstrate that British Israelism is absolutely ridiculous. The problem is that most of the members of the Cult of Herbert Armstrong Mafia do not have the talent to understand science. To them, it is magic. Not only is it magic, but it is magic which is flexible to bend to their beliefs and wishes. Most of the members have an appalling lack of scientific ability. As an illustration, over at the Ronald Weinland False Prophet blog, one of the former PKG members disclosed that they believed the world was flat. This created a storm of furor as others on the forum attempted to change the opinion of this person. The person actually cited some ‘proof’ materials and videos that the earth is flat.
One of the many problems of Armstrongism is that people make assumptions about others in their midst. People in the WCG sat with one another every week for decades and thought that they were all speaking (and believing) the same thing. The Tkaches come along and suddenly you find out that the people sitting next to you for all those years don’t at all believe the same thing you do. A great rift of divide ensued. The disparate viewpoints simply can not and have not been reconciled.
I hate science
The cult of Armstrong must be antiscience. There is no other choice. If people knew and understood science, they would know that what Armstrongism teaches is all lies. The alternative universe constructed from sheer conjecture simply cannot exist in our own universe. Germany isn’t going to head the European Union to begin World War III and send what’s left of the Americans and Brits into slavery — it isn’t going to happen in the next 3 to 5 years and it isn’t going to happen in 300 to 500 years. There will be no Place of Safety at Petra. It isn’t going to happen. Of course, the Armstrongists will live in denial because Winter has come for science in Armstrongism land.
As a result of ignoring science, Armstrongism will crumble and the Armstrongists — those few who are left — will fall into their own Dark Ages.
For a religion which preaches so much about God and claims He is the creator, the Armstrongists certainly hold God in contempt. If God really did create the universe and is behind all truth, then God is the ultimate Scientist, Technologist, Engineer and Mathematician. He has to be, because even with our advancements, we barely understand how things in the universe really work. It took years to map the human genome. Apparently God understands things so complex that even after another thousand years, humanity will still be in its infancy compared with God.
But the Armstrongists insult God. They make snide comments about ‘that DNA nonsense’. If you really believe God created everything, DNA isn’t nonsense and you had best take care because if God truly exists, He may forgive you for your deficiencies, but He certainly isn’t going to tolerate your defiance.
Beware! View the following video by Dr. Neil deGrasse Tyson about what happened to Islam when an Islamic scholar named Hamid Al-Ghazali deemed science evil:
The Armstrongist leaders want to be the .1% of the world ruling class with special privileges of power, wealth and prestige, free to pursue their passions, including Irish Dancing, without any accountability, dominating their peasants / Proles trapped in an agrarian dystopian society subject to magical thinking without science to release them from shackles through truth. The Armstrongists want to suppress science so they can ply their abuse upon hapless helpless miserable impoverished people without regard for their well-being or happiness. The damage they will do if they reach ascendancy will be collateral because they care only about themselves and their privileges. They will hold the world in superstition if they get the opportunity. And if they get their way…
Herbert Armstrong vs Dennis Luker demonstrated that men without ability, talent, experience and qualifications can build a successfully running cult while those with the qualifications don’t stand a chance within a dysfunctional organization. DBP poses an interesting question in the comments:
Do dysfunctional organizations, the ones that grow big enough to be noticed, spring forth from a cult-like minded sociopathic leader? You know, the ones who have no control over themselves so they try to control every body else.
It is an interesting question and one which could be addressed in various ways. Let us examine anecdotal evidence to illustrate.
Decades ago, there was a rather well-liked pastor of a particularly small church. He lived modestly and promised his congregation that no matter how successful or how large the church grew, he would always live in adequate but modest accommodations. At the time, his approach was humble and his intentions were sincere.
Fast forward several decades. That little church grew into a megachurch. Each weekend, thousands of people park their vehicles in the parking lot of the church on prime city property to be bused up to the tabernacle where there are fairly short ‘plastic services’ served up with choir singing and music, prayer and a short palliative service filled with the all-too-familiar bromides designed to evoke positive emotions of good feelings. It isn’t clear how many millions of dollars a year are collected in this cash cow, but it is substantial.
And the housing for the original pastor — who may or may not even be seen for any of the services?
Note the picture above of the Narrows Bridge over Puget Sound. He has a house near the water with a spectacular view. There isn’t any real guide of how much the pastor’s property is worth, but it is in the millions. As if this weren’t enough, he has built another similar property nearby for his daughter.
There isn’t anything illegal about this as far as anyone knows, but one dare not ask any questions, for, in the due process of time, he has become very well politically connected in the community and those who might cast aspersions upon him risk considerable personal damage as public (and official) opinion could cause ruin for anyone daring to pose anything concerning this pastor in a negative light.
Is the megachurch a cult? The pastor certainly was not a sociopath. What seems to have happened is that the good intentions did not live on with integrity. To understand this fully takes a nuanced approach. There is a very old saying, which is completely wrong, that power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely. If that were true, then God has to be the most corrupt being in the Universe. No, rather, power permits a person to become who and what they truly are. Early on, with integrity, a person may be able to disguise who and what they are and good intentions may be fulfilled, but as time passes, age leaves people frayed at the edges and often they will find it harder and harder to resist the temptations of taking advantage of, well, the advantages they have. This is especially true if there is no accountability, for, without it, a person can do and be anything they want to be with no consequences. In a situation like that, the true colors will come out and a person will truly be what they are. Early discipline and commitment are the only things standing in the way to prevent deterioration of integrity. Thus, it is not always true that a dysfunctional organization grows from a sociopathic leader, influencing and infecting the ranks below. Often, it is just the chaos which results from the loss of energy required to maintain integrity.
Some may think that the situation developed from narcissism, but that does not seem to be the case. Instead, there is a more subtle form of bias at the root of what happened. It is apparent that the pastor thought he was superior to others. Perhaps not everyone, but enough to believe that he should be able to be able to have more as an entitlement. This, combined with a lack of accountability, opened the way for the compromise of integrity.
To the north in three major metropolitan areas is yet another megachurch which hustles attendees to 90 minute services in cattle drive fashion. The founder has an interesting story. As a teenager, he was heavily involved with drugs. At the age of 19, he entered a drug rehabilitation center where he became ‘born again’ and supposedly learned how to renew his mind through the Bible, which he considered the Word of God. He went on to earn his bachelor of theology, married and eventually founded his ‘church’ which grew and grew and grew. The magachurch has a variety of ‘ministry’ with something for everyone — seniors, kids, teens, young marrieds, parents, young adults, a prison ministry, women’s ministry and, of course, recovery centers because there’s nothing like leveraging something you know.
Is the megachurch a cult? Is the ‘pastor’, who can be seen simulcast on Sunday on two screens in two locations, a sociopath?
That question is open to interpretation. On the surface, to all appearances, the man seems squeaky clean and appears to be just what he seems. However, the waitress at a Mexican restaurant saw him differently. He brought a party with him for dinner, was quite demanding and insisted on the best service. She described his offspring as ‘Nazi children’. He was rude to her. In the end, after being particularly nasty to her, he left without giving her any kind of tip. It’s amazing what some people are like when they deal with those they think are their helpless inferiors. Again, this is a situation where the man certainly made it plain that he felt he was superior, with more than an added layer of hubris.
As we turn our attention within this topic to Herbert Armstrong and the Cult of Herbert Armstrong Mafia he spawned, we have a background of behavior derived from a way of thinking: The person at the top, founding a religion with at least a modicum of bad behavior toward those thought to be inferior. The resulting dystopian misery — at least for some — is a result of the pattern of thinking which trivializes others. It doesn’t have to be full blown narcissism, it doesn’t necessarily represent full on antisocial behavior — in fact, there may not be any overt attempt at oppression or abuse, it may simply be a matter of collateral damage to people who just don’t matter that much to the person with superiority trivializing others. Certainly, being a sociopath or psychopath enriches the cultic environment, which is then propagated by those in the upper layers of the hierarchy to those below.
Certainly, Herbert Armstrong, given his incest during his first ten years of his ‘ministry’ was severely antisocial, and, as pointed out by David Robinson, if he had been caught in the State of Texas, he would have been executed. It was not as trivial as painted by apologists. Scripturally, his being a false prophet with the death penalty attached by Old Testament standards wasn’t trivial either, but modern apologists find excuses to vindicate his bad behavior, inimical to being any sort of competent minister, let alone human being. If God truly is his judge, Herbert Armstrong is going to have to come up with his own excuses on Judgment Day, as are all those who knowingly afforded him the idolatry they gave him as the one who ‘brought them the truth’ which was nothing of the kind.
As Herbert Armstrong progressed through the Church of God environment, he espoused the proposition that he was better than any one else. This went beyond simple superiority and encompassed full blown narcissism. He could not tolerate being subject to anyone else because he ‘knew’ he was superior and that no one had more knowledge or understanding than he. He found ways to rebel until he could stand on his own with a following so that he could have the freedom not to be subject to anyone. He wanted freedom from accountability. When he achieved that, a cult was the natural result. All sorts of extreme abnormalities ensued as he applied his eccentricity and egocentricity to religious doctrine. He amplified the effect of his antisocial stance by using indoctrination into insanity using Ambassador College. From there, the adaptation to the insanity became institutionalized, reinforced by inter social interactions providing a gestalt of the weird and creepy, including, but not restricted to, the science fiction of alternative earth history depicted by British Israelism, which, in turn, turned into an obsession among the cult members for seeking the ‘truth’ about the future, including the imminent destruction of the current societies of the world in a worldwide collapse of society, commerce and the financial institutions needed to support the world as it is today. This destruction and devastation was to usher in a fabulous world of peace and prosperity — in a scant few foreseeable years — which never has come to pass.
After Herbert Armstrong died, there was a vacuum which supplanted whatever order there was in the Worldwide Church of God held together by the force of will of Herbert Armstrong. Not only did he spend up the future with his indulgence leaving nothing but the potential for pent up entropy, but also conditions changed so that doing the same things under the same conditions to produce the same results could not be sustained because the world had changed forever such that it was harder and harder to maintain a selfish system wherein the leader could attain the same levels of lack of accountability, even though there were small pockets of remnant resources which could be protected from the ravages of entropy for a time.
Roderick Meredith was one of the first to venture forth to establish his own compound where he could expect to be superior to others without any accountability. His efforts were devastating, bankrupting the Global Church of God, as he plowed it under for his own selfish reasons. Today, he faces his impending death with his progeny supported at church headquarters as philandering boozing alcoholic adulterers. Problems multiply because more and more people associated with the Living Church of God are asking questions involving accountability, or rather, the lack of it.
David Pack is definitely one to assert his own superiority making others of much less worth in his own mind. He has come to the point that he is so filled with selfish hubris that he thinks and declares that everything is his. Members are to share everything in common, to give up their own rights, so he can take what everyone else has. He has no concept of accountability and what’s worse doesn’t seem to have any sense of what others think of him, nor does he particularly embrace any sort of reality about himself in his extreme shameless entitlement: What’s yours is his and what’s his is his. Ultimate collapse is the only destination possible in long term.
Gerald Flurry is ‘that prophet’ which means he is Jesus Christ in the flesh. He certainly sees himself as superior to others. As he regards his inferiors, he has pointedly said that ‘no one has any rights’. What he means is that only he has rights, his followers have none, he can do whatever he wants without one shred of accountability and no one has any right to question him or his ministers, not even to ask if it’s a particularly good idea to leave your disabled child at a shopping mall because someone will take care of it. Superiority also is projected in ‘the no contact rule’. Members of the Philadelphia Church of God may not have any meaningful (religious) contact with people outside the PCG, nor may they have contact with their own family if the family members don’t espouse Gerald Flurry doctrine and they can’t even have contact with other Armstrongist members of the Churches of God if they are not specifically members of the Philadelphia Church of God in good standing. Superiority has hubris added to it, with a huge serving of antisocial behavior, in the which, members encourage one another to reinforce this diabolical cult. There are also questions as to how Irish dancing contributes to the redemption of anyone in the world to bring them to the truth. How does that work exactly?
James Russell deserves special mention because the delimiting factor of whether or not you are a spirit led Christian is determined by whether or not you keep the postponements to the holydays. If you keep the postponements of the Jewish Calendar, you will be among those mentioned in Revelation 2 as those who are of ‘the blasphemy of them which say they are Jews, and are not, but are the synagogue of Satan’: You’ll be the ones who fall down and worship those of the Church of God in Truth who have become spirit beings.
Don’t worry about these things. These are sects of a cult, many of which are led by either sociopaths or psychopaths, but certainly are formed and led by those who are ‘holier than thou’ who believe that they are better than nearly anyone else and more often than not are arrogant, having compromised their humanity long ago in favor of being free from any accountability.